While
consumers have considered Boeing and Airbus the only rivals in creating large
innovative aircrafts, the market may have overlooked a rising dragon in the
East, China’s state owned Comac is
creating a C919 and C929 that will rival the Boeing and Airbus airplanes
(Cameron 2012). Comac’s C929 has been labeled a “game changer” in the industry
providing a 10% reduction in cost compared to Boeing and Airbus 3(Cameron
2012). The plane will carry 165-180 passengers and will benefit from China’s
growing need to replace retiring airplanes (Cameron 2012). An important point
advantage China has over Boeing and Airbus is supply of low cost labor in the
country. Although the article explains that this advantage is minimized when
looking at the bigger picture because most of the parts are from the west it
still will be a long term advantage over the United States and European labor
unions that increase labor costs (Cameron 2012). Also, it does not take a
country like China to build the know how to create these parts reducing the
competitive advantage of Boeing and Airbus in the long run. Increased
competition in the industry pushes downward pressures on prices decreasing
margins giving China’s labor cost and important strategic advantage. Comac has
had success and traction with their current C919 selling over 380 orders2.
The company is expecting to sell anywhere from 4,000- 20,000 airplanes over the
next 20 years3.
China’s state owned enterprises low
labor costs creating increased competition in the global market place is
important for every industry in the world. The country has a strategic
competitive advantage in low labor costs that pushes downward pressure on price
and increases competition globally. Also, it is important that we recognize
there is a new Asian tiger in the aircraft market providing competition for the
traditional Airbus and Boeing.
Implications of China becoming
competitive in the aircraft market means decreased margins for the top 2
aircraft companies. Downward pressure on prices will require that western
companies tighten supply chain and reduce the cost of materials or add value
that allows price competition to cease to exist. Managers should keep an eye
out for state owned enterprises that provide increased competition through low
labor costs.
1Cameron, D. (2012, Nov 09).
Plane makers under pressure to cut costs as competition looms. Wall Street
Journal (Online). Retrieved from http://search.proquest.com/docview/1143674269?accountid=7108
This is a current issue. However, this issue should have happened in 20 years ago. Developing big business airplane was one of main target about China 5-year plan in 1980th. Unfortunately, Boeing lobbied very hard to some China political leaders and promised provide near cost-price plane. As a result, this program was was axed by the government. Now, most of Chinese believe that decision was myopic.
ReplyDeleteThis issue shows the cost advantage, especially labor cost, of aircraft industry in China brings threat to the competitors in other countries. With the increasing demand of traveling by plane, the demand for airplane will rise too. it is a wise decision to develop its own airplane, which can not only promote the development of manufacturing industry of civil airplane, but also lead economic development in China.
ReplyDeleteIt is very interesting to understand the political underlying issues of the aircraft industry.It seems to be a protected industry in America and it will be interesting to see how China competes.
ReplyDelete